Seven in ten respondents say people are promoted for being good at their current job, not for being ready to lead. New Australian research reveals the challenges facing hospitality's next generation of managers, and what employers can do about them.
It's a familiar story in hospitality. The best bartender on the floor, the chef who never dropped a service, the supervisor everyone called when things went sideways. Then one week they're running the team.
Promoting from within is one of the industry's real strengths. New research from Collective Foundation suggests it also leaves a gap: people often step up before anyone has prepared them to lead. That raises a practical question for every operator. How do you prepare your next managers before they're promoted?
Shaping the Future of Hospitality Management Careers draws on 368 survey responses collected between August and October 2026, exploring career aspirations, management readiness and progression across Australian hospitality. The research was supported by OpenTable.
Promoted for performance, not always prepared to lead
The numbers on management readiness are blunt:
- 70.6% agree people are often promoted because they're good at their current job, not because they're ready to manage
- 65.3% say people become managers before they feel ready
- 68.3% say there isn't enough formal training before people step up
The skills that make a great bartender (speed, product knowledge, reading a room) aren't the skills that make a great bar manager. Management means coaching, rostering, handling conflict, reading a P&L and keeping people safe. Most new managers learn all of it with their team watching.
Management readiness is also a workplace safety issue
The report asked what puts people off pursuing management. The most common answers were weekend and evening work (75.1%), long hours (73.1%), stress and pressure (66.0%) and burnout (64.4%).
The report doesn't examine these findings through a workplace health and safety lens. However, they point to issues that can be associated with recognised psychosocial hazards, including excessive job demands, inadequate recovery time and poor workplace support. Managers are often well placed to recognise early warning signs, although responsibility for identifying and managing these risks sits with the business.
That's another reason to prepare managers before they step up, so they know what to look for and when to raise it.
Managers decide who stays
92.8% of respondents say managers have a major impact on whether staff stay or leave, and 93.3% say managers shape workplace culture.
Poorly supported managers can struggle to support their teams, particularly when staffing shortages and operational pressures are already high. That can create additional challenges for retention and workplace culture. The research measures perceptions rather than actual turnover, but it's a clear signal of how much rides on getting a new manager ready before they take on a team.
The retention gap starts young
Only 28.9% of under-25s want to stay in hospitality long term, compared with 53.3% of 25–34-year-olds. Another 34.2% of under-25s are open to staying but unsure.
That unsure group matters for leadership too. Today's under-25s are the supervisors and managers of the next decade. Career conversations that start in someone's first year, not after they've handed in their notice, help them see a path worth staying for.
Smaller venues have a harder job
80.4% say progression depends heavily on the venue or employer. 57.6% say smaller independent venues offer fewer senior roles, and 57.3% see larger groups as offering clearer pathways.
Pathway clarity seems to matter. Among respondents who could see a clear route into management, 51.6% wanted to stay in hospitality long term, compared with 28.9% of those who couldn't. The report is careful to note this is an association, not proof of cause, but it's hard to ignore.
A pub or independent restaurant can't create senior roles out of thin air. It can spell out what the next step involves, train people for it before they get there, and use external training and mentoring to give staff the development a large group would offer.
Training helps. It won't fix the roster.
A separate question asked respondents to choose the top three barriers to a long-term hospitality career, not just to management. The most common picks were weekend and evening work (49.2%), low pay relative to responsibility (46.9%) and long hours (40.6%).
No management course fixes those. Preparing managers needs to sit alongside realistic workloads, fair pay and proper support from the business. What preparation can do is make sure that when someone steps up, they aren't also learning the basics of leading people under pressure.
What to do before the next promotion
The findings suggest operators need to start developing future managers well before a position becomes vacant.
That means giving promising staff opportunities to take on more responsibility, whether it's running a shift, preparing a roster or dealing with a difficult customer. They need the chance to practise these skills with support, rather than learning everything once they're in charge.
The training gaps are also clear. Some 87.5% of respondents identified a need for more people leadership training, while 80.1% pointed to financial and commercial skills. Understanding responsibilities for staff safety and wellbeing should be part of that preparation too.
And not everyone wants to manage people. Clear career pathways should give staff a realistic picture of what management involves, while recognising that experienced employees can progress without necessarily becoming managers.
Build managers before you need them
Hospitality will always need people who can deliver excellent service, run a busy kitchen or keep a venue operating smoothly. But those skills are only part of what makes a successful manager.
The research points to a simple opportunity: identify potential leaders earlier, give them the skills and experience to succeed, and make sure they're supported when they step up.
The time to start developing your next manager isn't when the position becomes vacant.
Develop your next generation of hospitality leaders
Explore Allara's leadership and management courses, designed to help hospitality teams build practical skills in people management, communication and business operations.
About the research
Shaping the Future of Hospitality Management Careers (2026) was commissioned by Collective Foundation with support from OpenTable. It received 368 responses; most figures quoted here are based on the roughly 250 respondents who answered the relevant career questions. Respondents were mostly in Victoria (70.9%), in metropolitan areas (86.7%) and working in restaurants (73.8%), so the findings reflect workforce perceptions rather than the whole Australian industry.